
The question isn't whether you want pizza. On a Myrtle Beach trip, that answer shows up without much debate. The question pivots on something smaller: what kind of meal is this supposed to be? The one that fits into the gap between everything else — picked up fast, eaten on the move, no plan required — or the one that is the plan, with people around a table, plates appearing in order, nobody watching the clock?
Myrtle Beach has both. Marco Polo Pizzeria sits right off Ocean Boulevard, open late, walk-up accessible, the kind of place that earns its reputation at 11 p.m. with wet hair and a full day behind you. And somewhere off the strip, with a dining room that has been feeding the same neighborhood for more than three decades, Michael's Pizza, Pasta & Grill is doing something different: making pizza the anchor of an evening rather than the fill between events.
Neither is trying to be the other. That's why this comparison works.
Marco Polo Pizzeria on North Ocean Boulevard is purpose-built for the way vacations actually run — not the itinerary version, the real version, where people are scattered, everyone's hungry at slightly different times, and what you actually need is something hot that doesn't require a plan.
The location is the logic. One block from the water, outdoor seating on the boulevard, open into the late-night hours when most kitchens have already called it. A slice comes out fast. You can stand with it. You can eat it while watching Ocean Boulevard animate itself at the end of a summer night. Nothing about it requires coordination.
The menu runs wide — calzones, wings, stromboli, specialties — but the appeal for the impulse moment is simpler than that: it's a counter, it's late, it's on the way back. If you're the person whose trip tends to acquire momentum and lose structure, this is where you end up, and it tends to work.
Michael's Pizza, Pasta & Grill is a neighborhood restaurant in the truest sense of that phrase. More than thirty years in Myrtle Beach, on North Kings Highway, with a dining room built for the kind of meal that takes up two hours without apology. Hand-tossed New York-style pizza — crisp at the edges, chewy center — alongside a full Italian menu: pasta, calzones, subs, salads, homemade desserts like cannoli and tiramisu.
What this place reflects is a different relationship to pizza altogether. You're not filling a gap. You're building around it. The table is where the group lands for the night. The slices come out to share. Somebody orders pasta. Someone else is already talking about the cannoli before the pizza arrives.
Michael's also runs delivery to area hotels — a detail worth knowing for families who've had a long day and want the table-experience food without leaving the room.
Pizza is pizza. A good slice is a good slice. The setting is just scenery.
That's true enough when you're eating alone, or when it doesn't matter. But groups eat differently depending on where they sit. A walk-up counter and a dining room don't just change the backdrop — they change who orders what, how long people stay, whether anyone lingers. Patio seating on Ocean Boulevard makes people want to watch the street. A dining room with a full menu makes people want to try things.
The meal you're planning for isn't always the meal that happens. If your group has a tendency to scatter and reunite, Marco Polo's format absorbs that. If your group tends to cohere around a table and make it a thing, Michael's was built for exactly that. Pizza is the constant. The surrounding structure is the variable — and that variable shapes the experience more than the crust.
Marco Polo Pizzeria 513 N Ocean Blvd, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577 Right off the main drag — outdoor seating faces the boulevard. Hours run late; check their current hours and seasonal schedule directly, as late-night availability may vary: marcopolomyrtlebeach.com
Michael's Pizza, Pasta & Grill 1701 N Kings Hwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577 Lunch service typically begins at 11 a.m. Monday through Saturday; Sunday hours differ. Delivery available to area hotels. Patio dining with pet-friendly seating. Confirm current hours and any seasonal adjustments at their site: michaelspizzamyrtlebeach.com
Neither location requires reservations — both accommodate walk-ins. Street parking is available in the area around both; plan for seasonal congestion near the boulevard corridor.
The next time someone in your group asks "should we get pizza tonight," the answer is yes. What you're actually deciding is what tonight looks like. If it's a gap-fill after a full day on the water, walk up to Ocean Boulevard. If it's the night you want to sit down and make something of it, head to Kings Highway. The pizza doesn't decide — you do.
Want to feature your business on the DirectStay Blog?
Want to feature your business on the DirectStay Blog?
Connect with travelers, share your space, and join a community of hosts earning together.