A Mat-Su Valley dinner invites a question nobody warns you about: what if pizza is the whole plan? Not a concession to tired kids, not what you settle for when the glacier day ran long — the actual evening, built around crust and where you eat it. Mountain High Pizza Pie sits at the end of Main Street in Talkeetna, painted purple, Basilone family recipes turning out dough and sauce from scratch daily since 2003, garden herbs finding their way into specials you won't see anywhere else in the state. The deck faces the street. Live music drifts out through summer — several nights a week during peak season. Then there's the wood-fired version — seventy miles south in Wasilla, where four brothers who grew up in this valley started a brewery and then built the oven that changed what people came for.
Mountain High doesn't feel like a restaurant that planned its aesthetic. The purple paint happened and stayed. The Basilone family's recipes happened and deepened. The garden out back happened and started feeding the kitchen — fiddlehead ferns in spring, rhubarb when the season turns, salmon when the rivers deliver. What lands on your plate shifts with what the ground and the water are doing that week.
The menu holds its core — dough made daily, sauces from scratch, meats prepared in-house — but the specials board shifts with the season. Wild Alaskan salmon as a topping, rhubarb turning up in places you didn't expect, ingredients that don't exist in Lower 48 pizza.
Seating fills on its own schedule. On a busy summer evening, that means timing and patience — the place fills, the deck fills, and nobody rushes. The live music calendar runs deep: bands most weekends through summer, the annual anniversary party kicking off the season, acts ranging from bluegrass to Americana to whatever lands in Talkeetna that week. The pizza is the anchor, but the evening becomes the deck, the street, the mountains behind it all.
Kids fit here without effort. Families spread across the deck. The chocolate chip cookies come out warm. The soft serve appeared recently and already feels permanent. Nobody dressed up. Nobody needed to.
Bearpaw River Brewing in Wasilla started in December 2015 — four Wade brothers, all raised in this valley, all homebrewers who decided the hobby had outgrown the garage. The original spot on the Palmer-Wasilla Highway became "Little Bear": a 10-barrel system, five flagship beers, and the kind of taproom where regulars knew each other's trucks in the parking lot.
Then came "Big Bear" — the Railroad Avenue location in downtown Wasilla. The brothers tripled their brewing capacity and installed a wood-fired oven. The pizza wasn't tacked on to move more pints — it was central to what the second location was built to do.
What comes out of it surprises people who walked in expecting bar food. Cranberry cream cheese chicken pizza. Pear, bacon, and blue cheese. A pickle pizza that sounds wrong until it arrives. Whole roasted garlic cloves on the meat lovers. The crust carries char from the wood fire and chew from the dough, and the combinations lean creative without losing the thing that makes pizza work — it still feels like pizza, not a culinary experiment.
The beer list stays house-brewed: Hatcher Pass Pale Ale, Frontiersman IPA, Mat Maid Milk Stout, Humdinger IPA. Four brothers, all still involved, all still living in the valley. The taproom fills on Friday nights, live music outside in summer, and the families that come aren't choosing between beer and pizza — they came for both.
Seventy miles of road separates these two kitchens. Talkeetna sits at the end of the Spur Road, where Main Street is the whole story. Wasilla sprawls along the highway, commercial corridors mixed with neighborhoods, a town still deciding what it wants to become. The pizza in each place carries the personality of the town that made it.
Mountain High works because Talkeetna works — a place small enough that the purple building at the end of the street becomes a landmark on the first visit and a habit by the third. You're already walking Main Street. You've already passed Nagley's and the spinach bread line. The pizza is where the evening collects.
Bearpaw works because the Wades are from here. They're not importing a concept — they're feeding the town they grew up in, with an oven they built because they wanted to eat this way and nobody else was doing it. The regulars at Big Bear don't think of it as a brewery with food. They think of it as the place with the pizza and the beer, and they'll argue about which specialty pie is the current best.
🏠 HOST INSIGHT OPPORTUNITY:
"What do you tell guests about these places that they wouldn't find online?"
✅ IF HOST PROVIDES WISDOM:
"But the part that changes everything is [HOST INPUT HERE]."
⬇️ ALTERNATE (if no host wisdom):
"But the pattern regulars follow is this: if you're already in Talkeetna for the day, Mountain High is where the evening lands naturally. If you're based in Wasilla or Palmer and the day ran hard, Bearpaw is the dinner that doesn't ask anything of you except showing up hungry."
Where: 22165 S C St, Talkeetna — at the end of Main Street. The purple building.
Hours: Historically open Wednesday through Sunday, noon to 8 PM. Closed Monday and Tuesday. Verify current hours and seasonal adjustments at pizzapietalkeetna.com.
Reservations: Self-seating — find your own table. Summer evenings fill. Check pizzapietalkeetna.com for current reservation options.
Live music: Regular schedule through summer, typically weekends and select weeknights. Check their events page or Facebook for the current lineup.
Bearpaw River Brewing Company
Where: Two Wasilla locations. "Big Bear" at 240 E Railroad Ave (downtown Wasilla) — the wood-fired pizza location with expanded taproom. "Little Bear" at 4605 E Palmer-Wasilla Hwy — the original brewery.
Hours: Big Bear typically open daily. Little Bear historically weekday afternoons and weekends. Hours shift seasonally. Verify current hours at bearpawriverbrewing.com.
Reservations: Walk-in. Friday and Saturday evenings fill — plan accordingly.
Parking: Both Mountain High and Bearpaw have on-site or adjacent parking. Talkeetna's Main Street fills on summer evenings — arrive early or walk from nearby parking areas.
Lodging note: Both towns serve as base-camp options for Mat-Su visitors. Guests staying in Palmer face different drives — about twenty minutes west to Wasilla, roughly an hour and forty-five minutes north to Talkeetna. Building the pizza dinner into a full day in either town means the drive home becomes the wind-down, not the obstacle.
Two families made pizza the center of their work in this valley. One brought recipes to Talkeetna and planted them until the garden started feeding the kitchen back. The other grew up here, built the oven they wanted to cook in, and opened the door to their neighbors. The pizza question isn't about toppings or crust or which beer pairs better. It's about which town's evening you want to sit inside — the one at the end of the road, or the one that's still building.
Want to feature your business on the DirectStay Blog?
Want to feature your business on the DirectStay Blog?
Connect with travelers, share your space, and join a community of hosts earning together.
Become a host